Dynamics of Immobility: Capability Conversion Among Aspiring Migrants in Pakistan - Incite at Columbia University
-
Work
Dynamics of Immobility: Capability Conversion Among Aspiring Migrants in Pakistan
- Published May 10, 2021
- Authors Daniel Karell
- Category Paper
- Forum International Migration
- Link onlinelibrary.wiley.com
What are the costs of attempting to migrate internationally for work but being deterred by unexpected changes in states’ policies?
Building on recent insights into involuntary immobility, I examine immobility's financial consequences, including how these consequences vary across levels of household wealth. Drawing on an original panel survey of 70 aspiring Pakistani labour migrants and their heads of household, I find that poorer households more often expected to pay to migrate. They also lost the most in financing overseas employment attempts gone awry. I additionally use the findings to specify a dynamic of immobility: “capability conversion”, or the process by which migrants’ capability to migrate at one point in time crashes up against unexpected constraints, thereby affecting their future capability to migrate.
Related Projects
-
go to Research and Empirical Analysis of Labor Migration
Research and Empirical Analysis of Labor MigrationAddressing gaps in knowledge about temporary labor migration to the Gulf through ethnography, surveys, and workshops. Funded by New York University Abu Dhabi Institute
Related Works
-
go to the What If Local News Were Something You Could Walk Into?Aug 2026What If Local News Were Something You Could Walk Into? Terry Parris Jr,
-
go to the Hybrid Epistemology: Insights From a Crisis Collaboration Between Oral Historians and SociologistsMay 2026Hybrid Epistemology: Insights From a Crisis Collaboration Between Oral Historians and Sociologists Ryan Hagen, Denise Milstein, and Amy StarecheskiInternational Journal of Qualitative Methods, 25
-
go to the Inside Jobs: Prison Work in the American Labor MarketMay 2026Inside Jobs: Prison Work in the American Labor Market Adam Reich
-
go to the Democracy Denied at the Bedside: Union Avoidance in Minnesota’s Nursing Home SectorMar 2026Democracy Denied at the Bedside: Union Avoidance in Minnesota’s Nursing Home Sector Suresh Naidu, Adam Reich, McKenna Roberts, Easton Schindler, Niharika Singh, Patrick Youngblood
-
go to the Oral History and Anthropology: A Survey of Histories and PossibilitiesFeb 2026Oral History and Anthropology: A Survey of Histories and Possibilities Amy StarecheskiThe Oral History Review
-
go to the Exploring Mediation of Assistive Wayfinding Technologies through Professional Organizations for Blind and Low-Vision PeopleJan 2026Exploring Mediation of Assistive Wayfinding Technologies through Professional Organizations for Blind and Low-Vision People Jenny Fondren, Cristian Capotescu, Gil Eyal, Gaurav Jain, Jennifer Laird, Nicole Lum, and Brian Smith.Journal of Visual Impairment & Blindness 120, no. 1 (2026). Special issue on Advancements and Innovations in Technology for Individuals with Visual Impairments.
-
go to the Journalism establishes a physical presenceDec 2025Journalism establishes a physical presence Terry Parris Jr.
-
go to the What I’ve Learned (So Far) About Building With Libraries, Newsrooms and CommunitiesNov 2025What I’ve Learned (So Far) About Building With Libraries, Newsrooms and Communities Terry Parris Jr.
-
go to the I Have An Idea To Open 16,000 Newsrooms In The U.S.Nov 2025I Have An Idea To Open 16,000 Newsrooms In The U.S. Terry Parris Jr,
-
go to the The Discovery That Changed How I Think About Local NewsNov 2025The Discovery That Changed How I Think About Local News Terry Parris Jr.